Ok... so... wow... I've tried so many combinations of 6 totally maxed players that my mouse is complaining. I also tried making sure that they were not hungry, not tired, not thirsty, and not socially deprived, all at the same time. All else is solved and every other player is sitting around campfires waiting for the big moment. They're so tired of waiting, that I think they might just leave if it doesn't happen soon. There MUST be a formula!